Le Minh Khai's SEAsian History Blog (+ More)

A couple of years ago, I published an article entitled “Rescuing History from Srivijaya: The Fall of Angkor in the Ming Shilu (Part 1).” A continuation of that article, “Rescuing History from Srivijaya: The Fall of Angkor in the Ming Shilu (Part 2),” has just been published, and at some...

As I have said a million times by now, there is a place name in Chinese historical sources, Sanfoqi 三佛齊, that in the early twentieth century, French scholar George Cœdès claimed indicated a place called “Srivijaya,” a polity supposedly based at Palembang on the island of Sumatra. As I have...

Off and on over the past few years, I have been researching about a place called “Sanfoqi” 三佛齊. This is a name that appears in Chinese sources from the tenth through the fourteenth centuries, and it was clearly a very important trading center in Southeast Asia. Since the early twentieth...

I’ve recently published a working paper entitled “Revisiting the Chinese Sources on Early Southeast Asia.” I started looking at the Chinese sources for early Southeast Asian history a few years ago, and discovered a lot of problems with the ways that modern scholars have understood and written about those materials....

The scholarship on early Southeast Asian history that relies on Chinese sources is a complete mess. From the very beginning, scholars got a lot of things wrong, and then they just kept going and kept producing ever more flawed scholarship. By this point, the extant scholarship is simply unusable. If...

Chinese historical sources have long been used to try to gain an understanding of early Southeast Asian history. However, when scholars have made use of these sources, they have usually done so without talking about the context in which that information is placed in Chinese historical sources. In other words,...

I have recently been writing a lot about a place that I refer to as “Jāba,” a kingdom that I argue was based in the area of what is now Songkhla in southern Thailand and which from the fifth to fourteenth centuries was an important node in a trans-peninsular trade...

By now I think that I have clearly established the fact that there was a kingdom located in the area of what is now Songkhla that was at the center of an important trans-peninsular trade network. I refer to this kingdom as “Jāba” (although it may have actually been called...

In 1810, two Vietnamese officials presented to Emperor Gia Long a map of the routes to, and within parts of, Siam with an accompanying text based on information they had acquired the previous year while on a diplomatic mission. Known as the Collected Records of the Routes in the Kingdom...

In many recent posts, I have been writing about a place that I call “Jāba.” This was the center of a major trans-peninsular trade empire, and it was located around the area of what is now Songkhla in southern Thailand. This place is referred to in various historical sources by...

In the eleventh century, a place in Southeast Asia called “Srivishaya” was attacked by a kingdom from southern India known as the Chola kingdom. We know about this from inscriptions in Sanskrit and Tamil that have been found in India. What we also know from these inscriptions is that prior...

In early 1292, Kublai Khan, the Mongol emperor of the Yuan Dynasty in China, gave orders to three of his officials to lead troops to attack the island of Java. Why did he do this? The History of the Yuan states that when these men met with the emperor before...

Yes, you read that correctly. Marco Polo visited Thailand. Ok, I know that there was no place called “Thailand” in the late thirteenth century when Marco Polo traveled across Southeast Asia on his way back to Venice, however, he did pass through places that are now part of Thailand. This...

Ok, I think I have finally found “Malayu”!!! The term, “Malayu,” and the related terms of Malaya and Malāyur appear in several historical sources before the 1400s, and they clearly refer to a place. Where was that place? In a previous post, where I debunked the idea that Tang Dynasty...

Having shared the translations of some of the information in Arabic texts about Southeast Asia in the last post, let’s take a look at what they have to say about the place called Jāba/Zābaj, which I argue was a trans-peninsular trading empire that was based at Songkhla in what is...

In recent posts, I have been talking about information in Arabic texts. There are a group of texts in Arabic that provide information about Southeast Asia starting in the ninth century. I can’t read Arabic, so I have to rely on translations, and there are a couple of main translations...

As stated in the previous post, there were two “Javas” in the past in Southeast Asia. These two Javas are referred to in Arabic, Chinese and other sources variously as Java/Jaba/Zabag/Shepo and mul-Java/Zhuawa. Originally only one Java was mentioned in historical sources. Then in the 1200s and 1300s both of...

One issue that has confused historians for over a century is the fact that there is more than one place that was referred to as “Java” (or something close to that name) in the past in Southeast Asia. I think this can be seen the clearest in Chinese sources, but...

There was a Chinese Buddhist monk by the name of Yijing 義淨 (635–713) who traveled to India in the second half of the seventh century and stayed there for 11 years. Yijing left some records of his journey, and that information has served as “evidence” for the existence of a...

The belief that there was historically a dynamic and important maritime kingdom on the island of Sumatra called “Srivijaya” has created an incalculable number of problems for scholarship on premodern Southeast Asian history. This is because, over the past century, scholar after scholar after scholar has interpreted historical sources with...

A colleague and friend pointed out to me that I should look at information in a work known as The Crystal Sands: The Chronicles of Nagara Sri Dharrmaraja. This is a Thai-language text that was translated into English and published in 1975 by the late historian David K. Wyatt. Cornell...

A while ago I made a video where I said something like “no place called Srivijaya ever existed”. . . I kind of knew at the time that I might end up eating those words, but I like to be provocative, and I had a strong sense at that time...

At long last, the first part of a 2-part article on “Srivijaya” has just been published. In this article, I argue that information in Chinese sources (about “Sanfoqi” 三佛齊) that has been used to construct the history of a supposed maritime polity in Southeast Asia called “Srivijaya” is actually about...

I have recently come up with a new picture of premodern Southeast Asian history by revisiting Chinese, Siamese, and Cambodian sources. In particular, I have come to conclude that there was never a place called “Srivijaya,” a kingdom that was supposedly “rediscovered” by George Cœdès in 1918. Instead, I am...

As I stated in the previous post (The “One Country – One King” Problem in Premodern Southeast Asian History), when historians have looked at the records of tribute missions to China from Southeast Asian polities in the past, they have generally viewed those records as representing tribute missions from individual...

There is a major problem that plagues the scholarship on premodern Southeast Asian history, and I call it the “one king – one country” problem. When European scholars during the colonial period first examined Southeast Asian history and tried to develop political chronologies for the various polities in the region,...

I can see everything clearly now. It all falls into place. It all makes sense. . . Over the past couple of years, I have provided extensive evidence to overturn the idea that there was ever a maritime kingdom called “Srivijaya.” This supposed kingdom was “discovered” by French scholar George...

I am well aware that many people are going to respond with immediate disbelief to the idea of the article that I am about to publish that there was no “Srivijaya” and that the information in Chinese sources about “Sanfoqi” that was employed to produce a history for “Srivijaya” is...

I have recently written a long 2-part article that demonstrates that there was never a kingdom called “Srivijaya.” The first part will be published in a few days. Much of the information that was used to create the history of that supposed kingdom came from Chinese sources, and I have...

[Update: As I’ve researched this further, I’ve changed my mind a little bit. I still am 1 billion % sure that the “Srivjaya” that has been talked about in academic writings – that is, a supposed maritime polity based at Palembang – did not exist. What I think the “Srivjjaya/Srivishaya”...

The Google Ngram Viewer shows how many times certain terms appear in digitized printed texts. The image below shows what we see when we input the terms “Srivijiya” and “Sri Vijaya” in the Google Ngram Viewer. The Google search engine can show us how many websites contain a term that...

George Cœdès (1886-1969) was a French scholar of the Southeast Asian past who published prolifically, and through his writings, has exerted an enormous influence on the writing of premodern Southeast Asian history. Those writings include extensive translations of Cambodian inscriptions and a survey of early Southeast Asian history that was...

On 8 October 1431, the king of Chuzan 中山, one of the principalities that made up the Kingdom of Ryukyu on the island of Okinawa, sent a letter to the King of Siam. It was a very polite letter, as diplomatic letters tend to be. But the king of Chuzan...

In these posts I have been demonstrating that a Chinese name (Sanfoqi) that scholars think refers to a kingdom on the island of Sumatra (Srivijaya) actually referred to “Kambuja,” that is, Cambodia, or more specifically, to the kingdom of Angkor. All of the evidence that I have presented supports this...

As I stated at the beginning of this series, there is the name of a kingdom in Chinese sources, Sanfoqi, that scholars have long argued indicates “Srivijaya,” the name of a kingdom that supposedly existed on the island of Sumatra. As I have demonstrated in this series, prior to the...

As we saw in an earlier post, there is a chronology for fourteenth-century Cambodian history that is recorded in a group of chronicles that we can call the Nong texts. As we also saw, the Ming shilu, a Chinese historical source that contains information from the fourteenth century, contains a...

To be able to understand the information that the Ming shilu 明實錄 (Veritable Records of the Ming) contains about Cambodia in the fourteenth century, we have to also get a sense of what that text records about the neighboring Siamese polity of Ayutthaya, because as we saw in the previous...

For Cambodian history, there are various chronicles that record information, and the main chronicles begin by discussing events in the fourteenth century. However, the current versions of these chronicles were compiled much more recently, starting in the early nineteenth century. In particular, in the early nineteenth century there was a...

In 1979, French archaeologist Claude Jacques published an article that has been frequently cited entitled “‘Funan,’ ‘Zhenla’: The Reality Concealed by these Chinese Views of Indochina.” In this article, Jacques criticized historians for relying too heavily on employing Chinese sources in reconstructing the history of early Cambodia as he felt...

Chinese sources (the Ming shilu) record that in the late fourteenth century there was some kind of conflict between a place called Sanfoqi and Java, and that for some reason the Ming Dynasty emperor believed that Siam (Ayutthaya) was in a position to communicate with Java to alleviate this conflict...

In 1377, the kingdom of Sanfoqi sent an envoy to the Ming court to request an official seal for the Sanfoqi monarch. The Ming Hongwu Emperor obliged, and sent an envoy to deliver the seal. That Ming envoy, however, never made it to Sanfoqi. Instead, word eventually reached the Ming...

In the previous post, we saw that in various Chinese texts dating from the Song to the Ming periods, there was a kingdom called Sanfoqi that was located in the area of what is now Cambodia. What we didn’t talk about in that post, is the fact that during the...

Sanfoqi is the Chinese name of an historical kingdom that scholars believe once existed on the island of Sumatra and was called “Srivijaya.” I disagree. I am 100,000% convinced that Sanfoqi referred to “Kambuja,” that is, the Cambodian empire based at Angkor. One of the clearest ways to see this...

Several months ago, I spent a couple of weeks quickly researching and writing about “Srivijaya.” That is the name of a purported kingdom that was based at Palembang on the island of Sumatra and which supposedly flourished from roughly the seventh to thirteenth centuries. The posts that I wrote at...